Bud's pet goldfish, Dorothy, died this weekend. She has been unwell for a long time. She had a
close call last March and she
pulled through, though she's never really been the same since.
I've been thinking about Dorothy's eventual death since she took ill last year, so I've had plenty of time to plan - though I've had no real sense of how Bud would react. He
loves his fish, and he talks about them like they're family members. He offers frequent, unprompted declarations of his affection for them: "I love my pets Dorothy and Stevie!" But I didn't want to project onto him what he
should feel or inspire uncertainty where none existed, so I decided I'd just react as events unfolded.
For the past couple of weeks we've been watching Dorothy struggle to stay upright as her gills and tail began turning black. I've been planting small seeds with Bud:
Dorothy is very sick. Not the regular kind of sick - a different kind of sick.
Yesterday afternoon Bud was playing on the computer and Nana came upstairs to let me know that the end was near. I broke the news to Bud.
"Remember when we talked about Dorothy being very sick? Not regular sick?"
"Yeah."
"Well, honey, now she is dying. That means it's time for her to leave us and go to heaven."
"And she will be back soon?"
"No, sweetie. She doesn't get to come back from heaven. She has to stay in heaven, where she will be very happy and she won't be sick anymore. Do you want to go downstairs and say goodbye to her?"
"Goodbye to Dorothy?"
"Yes."
"Stevie's friend?"
"Yes. And we can tell Stevie that it will be okay and that we'll take care of him."
So down the stairs we went. Dorothy was lying on her side near the bottom of the bowl, barely breathing.
Bud peered in and put his nose against the side of the bowl. "She's sleeping?"
"No, honey. She's not sleeping. She's dying. It's almost time for her to go to heaven."
"Goodbye, Dorothy," he said. "We'll miss you."
"We love you, Dorothy," I added.
Bud turned to me. "I can go back to computer now?"
"Sure, honey."
Dorothy died about 30 minutes later, and Nana removed her from the bowl. I told Bud that Dorothy was gone, and asked him if he wanted to go talk to Stevie. He said no.
Poor Stevie is a wreck. He's spent most of his life being bossed around the bowl by the bigger, more dominant Dorothy. It was startling to watch as, over the past few weeks, Dorothy started shrinking and Stevie became the fish in the power position. But he continued to defer to Dorothy, trying to nudge her to the surface when it was time to eat, falling still as she lay struggling for breath. Now, without her, he's darting crazily around the bowl, all bulging eyes and twitching tail.
Bud, in contrast, is serene. He hasn't asked about Dorothy, and he's given Stevie only a fleeting glance. We told him that Dorothy is in a happy place, and it seems he has taken us at our word.
We had planned to buy another goldfish to try to ease the loss for Bud, but as it turns out Bud is just fine. I guess we have to turn our attention instead to the family member who needs it most.
The question is: how do we figure out how to ease the loss for Stevie?